WARNING: This article contains spoilers for the 1st and 2nd parts of the fourth season of the TV series YOU.
SCORE: 3.5/5 (Sorry Joe)
So much to say…
But let me say this first: The fourth season ends by crumbling under the sheer force that has over the years, made fans love YOU.
Viewers root for Joe Goldberg, not because he’s a good person, but because the show writers have cultivated his character to get away with doing bad things because of their justification, which he repeatedly communicates to himself and the viewers, via his thought process. He is what you’d call an Anti-hero.
Kind of what most people felt at the end of season three. We rooted for Joe while he was lying helplessly on the floor paralyzed by Aconite administered by his then (equally psychotic) wife, Love Quinn.
Which is why it’s ironic in the season four finale that when the song “Anti-hero” by Taylor Swift starts playing, I just want to throw away my phone and regurgitate my lunch all over it. I no longer have any love left for Joe’s character. HE JUST FRAMED A YOUNG GIRL FOR MURDER!

That scene where Joe hands Nadia the knife he used to stab her boyfriend was really painful to watch. Every inch in my body was praying Joe would finally (as he so loves to say) do the right thing.
I understand the motives behind his actions, and honestly feel – in part – sorry for him, but all I want is for him to FINALLY own up to his mistakes and not justify them. Now that would be real character development. The character grows, learns from their past mistakes. Which would have made so much sense if he’d actually died when he threw himself over that bridge. That would have been super anti-heroic.
What we get in the season finale however is instead the finishing of a complete circle, a 360 degrees turn around, back to where we started in season one.
We once again go to season one’s Joe Goldberg, figuratively and even literally, given he adopts his old name along with the past baggage that comes with it. So much for starting the season telling viewers all he wants is a “fresh start”. But no. Back to square one.
However, the show is bigger than Jonathan Moore.
Speaking of circles, Kate Lockwood comes to the profound realization that she can’t run away from the Lockwood name after all.

We are taken through an entire season of her fighting to escape the shadow of her controlling Father only to be taken back to where it all started, now as head of the Lockwood business. Again, the show fails to make any real strides in developing another character.
My heart goes out to Marienne. I hope she recovers from all this trauma she’s had to deal with. Her only crime was working at a library.

Phoebe is the biggest winner here. She runs off to Thailand to teach English to elementary students. She does find her thing in the end.
That said, I think the series does maintain its thrilling edge-of-the-seat bingeworthiness. And we get that mid-season shocker when we find out that Rhys Montrose isn’t actually the killer, it’s Professor Jonathan Moore, who has apparently dissociated and clearly lost his god-damned mind.

The ensuing psychic state that pits Joe against Rhys, who represents the darker side that Joe has shunned and denied since season one, really brings the kind of nuanced duality that you might look for in a crime drama.
Till next year I guess….

