Business

URA Under Fire after Losing a 2.4bn Tax Appeal Case

URA Under Fire after Losing a 2.4bn Tax Appeal Case

On June 23, the commercial court set aside a decision by the Tax Tribunal that ordered A Better Place Uganda Ltd to pay 2.4bn to the tax body.

The brief facts of the case are that on October 10, 2018, the appellant (A Better Place Uganda Ltd) filed an application against an assessment by the Uganda Revenue Authority, of 8.3 trillion for the period of February 2017 to October 2017. On October 18, 2018, upon the application by the appellant, the Tax Appeals Tribunal (TAT) issued a temporary injunction restraining URA from collection of the assessed tax and ordered the parties to agree on how the 30% of the assessed tax shall be paid.

Following guidance from the TAT, the two parties entered into partial consent settlement order on April 2, 2019. It was agreed that the parties conduct and conclude a reconciliatory exercise within two months; that the appellant pays UGX 250,000,000 towards reduction of the disputed taxes assessed by URA; and that the URA does not enforce recovery of the tax assessed during the said period of two months. All the matters agreed upon were since followed and each party fulfilled its responsibilities.

However, in a shocking turn of events, when the matter appeared before the TAT on August 5, 2019, no progress report of the reconciliation exercise had been filed by both parties. URA instead prayed to the tribunal to enforce payment of the 30% of the tax in dispute, failure of which the application should not proceed. Consequently, the tribunal accepted URA’s prayer and dismissed the appellant’s application for failure to pay the 30% of the tax in dispute.

Upon dissatisfaction, A Better Place Uganda lodged its appeal in the High Court (Commercial Division) on the following grounds;

  1. The Honorable tribunal erred in law in not hearing the Applicant’s case when it should have ordered for furnishing security for due performance in lieu of the cash constituting 30% of the tax in dispute; thereby denying the appellant to access justice.
  2. The Honorable tribunal erred in law in not recognizing that the additional UGX 250,000,000 was paid by the appellant and agreed to by URA in lieu of the 30% of the tax in dispute.
  3. The Honorable tribunal erred in law in enforcing 30% tax in dispute not provided for in the substantive tax legislation; the Tax Procedure Code Act, the Income Tax Act and the VAT Act.
  4. Whether the Tax Appeals Tribunal Act Cap 345 takes precedence over the Tax Procedure Code Act, 2014 in tax dispute resolution.

In a case that was tabled before Hon. Mr. Justice Boniface Wamala, the firm, A Better Place Uganda won the Shs 2.4bn tax appeal. The judge noted that failure to accord the company a fair hearing and access to justice led to a wrong decision by the TAT. “The decision to dismiss a tax appeal by A Better Place Uganda Ltd was done without fair hearing, contrary to the law of natural justice” asserted Justice Boniface Wamala. “The appeal partly succeeds and the order of the tribunal dismissing the application of the appellant is accordingly set aside”, he added.

Through its lawyer, Bernard Olok, the company petitioned the tribunal over claim of exorbitant tax assessment, adding that his client was unfairly evaluated.

However, according to Ronald Baluku, URA’s lawyer, section 15 of the TAT Act requires that a taxpayer must pay 30% of the tax assessed. He further told court that the claim by the company that the tax tribunal disregarded part payment of Shs 250 million was false. He said that the 30% of the tax assessed amounted to Shs 2.4bn, which the company had not paid and was in contravention of section 15 of the TAT Act.

The tax tribunal was set up by an act of Parliament as a specialized court to provide tax payers with easily accessible, efficient and independent arbitration in ax disputes with URA.

Solomon Ayebare
Author
Solomon Ayebare