“There was a bit of disagreement between the Justices” – Judiciary spokesperson on Supreme Court drama
The Judiciary spokesperson, Solomon Muyita, has come out to clear the air about the drama that transpired in court on Thursday.
Justice Esther Kisakye accused Chief Justice Owiny-Dollo of confiscating her file on the minority ruling in Bobiwine’s election petition.
Lights and the public address system were both switched off as Kisakye addressed the press after all her colleagues on the panel of nine judges refused to return to the court as had been earlier agreed.
Kisakye said that the Chief Justice, Dollo, had ordered for the confiscation of her dissenting file which presented the minority ruling on the election petition by Bobiwine. She also said that Dollo had ordered court to adjourn in order to prevent her from reading her dissenting ruling on the matter.
“The Chief Justice’s order to read my ruling at a later date is unconstitutional and that’s why I disobeyed it,” said Justice Kisakye.
In his bid to provide the public with answers, the spokesperson, Solomon Muyita, today while speaking to media on NBS television, acknowledged the drama that ensued in court, saying that it was all because of a miscommunication between the justices.
“Yesterday, there was some bit of disagreement between the justices,” he said, “The Chief Justice sent for her (Kisakye) and when she came, she said she wasn’t willing to share her ruling. The other justices didn’t find this proper so they didn’t follow her to the courtroom.”
And on the adjournment of the court, Solomon remarked: “And when the CJ saw that something wasn’t right, that’s when he decided to move the matter to a later date,” he said.
“Previously, Justice Kisakye had received copies of the other justices and they expected the same from her. That doesn’t mean they intended to change anything,” he added.
On switching off lights and the public address system, Muyita said the adjournment of the court meant that systems had to be shut down until it reconvened again.
“Systems had to be switched off on the understanding that when the lady justice is ready, the court would reconvene. Indeed the court was to reconvene and she would have her time to read her ruling as court had made her decision.”
Responding to the spokesperson’s remarks, Dr. Samuel Kazibwe, Ugandan broadcast journalist, academic and researcher cited precedent, saying that what happened in court ‘is not a shocker.’
“What we observed yesterday is not a shocker in Uganda’s politics though it is worth talking about. Drawing from what Onapito has said, we are close to the tipping point as a country.”
“A few years later, Kyagulanyi goes to the same court. A few days later, he chooses to withdraw his petition and gives reasons not different from the ones Besigye gave in 2006,” he added.

