Business

The stimulus package has failed to address MSMEs Needs – CSOs

The stimulus package has failed to address MSMEs Needs – CSOs

Civil Society Organisations and representatives from the private sector have expressed concern over the disbursement and management of the funds allocated to stimulus package by the Uganda Government.

In a bid to curb the spread of Covid-19, the Government put in place a number of measures including restrictions on transport and closure of non-essential businesses among others. It is with this that unemployment rates spiked due to the impact the measures had on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises who comprise of over 90% of the Private Sector in Uganda. These were hit most through the supply, demand and financial shocks.

As away of cushioning MSMEs from the impacts of the pandemic, in April 2020 the Government of Uganda put in place the economic Stimulus Package with an objective of supporting MSMEs and other business Enterprises that were hit hard by the pandemic and we’re struggling with major cash flow challenges.

It is important to note that the Government did not start up new programmes for this purpose aforementioned but rather looked at the already existing programmes and recapitalized them with the objective of offsetting the economic impacts that came asdl a result of the Covid-19 curbing measures.

Among the programmes capitalized to serve the objective of offsetting the Covid-19 economic impacts that have come to be known are the stimulus packages, whose economic objectives vary from supporting the Covid-19 Health related expenditures and support scientists and innovators engaged in various Covid-19 interventions, to re-igniting business activity through; providing credit via Savings and Credit Cooperative Societies (SACCOs) and Micro Finance Institutions to support MSMEs, increase access to credit at Uganda Development Bank (UDB) to offer low interest financing to manufacturing, agribusiness and other private sector firms, establish Microfinance Recovery Fund, targeting small and medium sized enterprises, among others.

However, Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) report that of the 1 trillion shillings that had been committed by the Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development, UDB received a disbursement of 455 billion in mid-August, 2020.

But in January 2021, the Uganda Development Bank stated that it disbursed up to 242 billion shillings to vital sectors of the country.

These funds were meant to support projects engaged in primary agriculture, agro-industralization, manufacturing,Tourism and Hospitality, infrastructure and Health Services.

However, the stringent conditions put in place by UDB like not lending out money below sums of 100 million shillings to enterprises, has curtailed access to these funds.

Joanita Nassuna, a program assistant at the Southern and Eastern Africa Trade and Negotiations Information Institute – SEATINI Uganda states other factors that have hindered access to this money, which include the demand for feasibility studies or business plans, need to provide a copy of each of the last 2 years audited/draft accounts (from Institute of Certified Public Accountants of Uganda/Bank of Uganda listed audit firms), security for the proposed loan, with current valuations of the assets all which MSMEs can hardly conform to.

She also notes that in addition to this, the bank has explicitly stated these funds are not meant to support MSMEs or struggling businesses, but are rather meant for the Bank’s recapitalization.

Nassuna says such lack of clarification leaves questions on whether there were any packages meant for MSMEs and whether the Government even had them in mind while designing these packages.

Now CSOs together with SEATINI Uganda and representatives from the Private Sector have set out recommendations and proposals for the Government regarding the UDB funds, stretching that the modalities being used to select the beneficiaries have been largely skewed towards already established large players with limited focus on struggling smaller enterprises.

Recommendations;

. As the Government of Uganda is planning to recapitalize Uganda Development Bank, it should review and address the identified challenges forexample, the minimum loan sum; coupled with the high interest rates, and the intended beneficiaries.

. UDB should review the stringent eligibility criteria being used to qualify and disburse the entrusted funds.

. UDB should also periodically publish the list of the beneficiaries as part of the accountability process to the general public.

. UDB should negotiate the loan conditionalities with the Uganda Manufacturers Association – UMA to allow UMA members access the Stimulus Package with favorable conditions as opposed to individual members.

. Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development should develop a comprehensive Covid-19 Stimulus response plan taking into considerations the MSMEs who have been impacted by Covid-19.

. Ministry of Finance, planning and Economic Development and respective agencies like UDB, Microfinance Support Center and others should exhibit more transparency in the manner in which the Stimulus Package is designed for the benefit of vulnerable Ugandans impacted by Covid-19.

. The International Monetary Fund should not only stop at disbursing loans to developing countries like Uganda but should be able to hold Government accountable to it’s commitments made when requesting for the Stimulus Package.

But on the other hand, John Walugembe, the Executive Director of the Federation of Small and Medium Enterprises – FSME has asked that the disbursement of funds be taken away from UDB, for it lacks clarity in it’s work.

He says if it ever came to ranking performance UDB would be given 30% while Micro Finance Support Centre – MFSC would be at 60%.

Walugembe notes that MSFC has so far performed fairy well but still lacks in some departments like, the issuing of the Certificate of Registration which is given out by only person, meaning everyone has to wait for when he makes himself available.

Sheenaz Namutawe
Author
Sheenaz Namutawe