National

New Coffee Deal: Ramathan Ggoobi Responds To Growing Concerns.

New Coffee Deal: Ramathan Ggoobi Responds To Growing Concerns.

The Permanent Secretary for the Ministry of Finance, Ramathan Ggoobi has spoken out to address public concerns about the new controversial agreement that Government has signed with Uganda Vinci Company Limited through the Finance Ministry.

In a lengthy note released via his Twitter page, Ggoobi responded to issues raised by the large scale coffee farmer and investor, Robert Kabushenga while appearing on NTV  Thursday night.

“Last night, I tuned into On the Spot (programme) on NTV Uganda, where a prominent coffee farmer, my friend Robert Kabushenga, MP Abed Bwanika and Jane Nalunga were hosted to chew more on the now much-discussed agreement that my Ministry signed with Vinci Uganda Coffee on February 10, 2022. Asked what is his pain, Robert said he feared that the agreement will block him from entering pre-sale deals for coffee beans with buyers in Europe, which in turn could hurt his plan to get financing for his planned coffee processing plant,” Ggoobi said.

Ministry of Finance recently signed a deal with Uganda Vinci Coffee Company Limited to establish a coffee processing plant at Namanve industrial park where which Italian businesswoman Enrica Pinetti signed on behalf of the company.

Ggoobi said that Government’s decision to sign this deal was to find a way to export coffee in its finest, finished form and attract more value from it.

“The European buyers may pay Kabushenga a slightly better price than they offer our less advantaged farmers because his coffee is of better quality and he can bargain a bit more. But the bottom line is that we shall continue to export raw, low value coffee. The question we face is simple: How do we get to export our coffee in its finest, finished form and capture a lot more value from it? It’s the same question Ghana faces with its cocoa. And we have been here for so many decades. The current global market value is $460 billion.”

Ggoobi argued that if Uganda can process it’s coffee to fine, finished products, the country can get nine times more monetary value out of it, approximately $5.4bn a year. In addition, more Ugandan citizens would be employed in the coffee chain here at home, among other advantages.

Pinetti who signed on behalf of Uganda Vinci Coffee Company Limited was also involved in the deal for the constriction of Lubowa International Specialized Hospital which has since stalled.

On the concerns why Government did not organise enterprising local coffee investors like Kabushenga to do the processing or send out an international call for investors into the sector instead of engaging Uganda Vinci, Ggoobi said the Coffee giant is the investor that came forward with a plan in line with what the Government wanted to achieve.

“Anyone can answer this question any way they want. But Vinci is the investor that came forward with a plan to do what the government wanted to be done. They offered to invest $80m to process coffee here, and then sell it in virgin markets in Europe and elsewhere,” he said, adding that, “the cost and risk of penetrating those virgin markets are for Vinci to shoulder. All the Government has done is to provide Vinci with a measure of incentives that are available to every strategic investor – in coffee, dairy, iron and steel, name it.”

There have been several worries around the incentives that Government has given the Italian company in the agreement, with some referring to them as overboard and ridiculous.

According to the terms of the agreement, the Company was given exclusive rights to buy all of Uganda’s coffee whereas it was also exempted from paying taxes including income tax, pay as you earn, Excise Duty, Stamp Duty, VAT, Import Duty and corporate income tax.

The Permanent Secretary said that these incentives are similar to what any other investors have always been given to encourage them to invest in a bid to steer the development of the export sphere of the country.

“The incentives that have been availed to Vinci, just like it happens for other investors – local or foreign – are for the first 10 years. It is just to help it lay a foundation. Government has done the same to so many other businesses that have played a role in Uganda’s development,” Ggoobi defended.

“After Vinci has penetrated the virgin markets and starts making profits, the incentives we are discussing will no longer be available to it, and it will pay all the taxes due to the Government. This is the plan for all investors who get incentives.”

He said that the agreement is a win-win solution for everyone as in the end, we the country shall produce more coffee, and ensure that most of it is premium.

Osbert Mwesigye
Author
Osbert Mwesigye