Columnists

OpEd: Is Ugandan democracy a farce or simply misunderstood?

OpEd: Is Ugandan democracy a farce or simply misunderstood?

Considering the classical definition, Politics is the science of managing society, precisely understanding society needs problems and inadequacies and chart solutions and consolidating the societal strengths. But in recent times in the narrow picture of Uganda, the definition is limited, redefined by the zealous demagogues or misguided elite. Perhaps politics in Uganda’s opposition lenses is a process of selection, which weeds out all but those who suffer from a specific type of cognitive deficit that makes a specific group or person cling to power. Sensible people, those who have the ability to tell when they’re not wanted, simply don’t make it to positions of great authority(that’s a discussion for another day). They give up far too early

But regardless of the psychological underpinnings, there is no escaping the observation that political leaders tend to quit long after their marginal contribution has fallen below zero or propaganda has demonised them well enough to depopularize (if that exists) them. Then comes a question, ”is the electoral democracy in Uganda or the process of selecting leadership effective? A farce? Or simply misunderstood?

To help tackle this question we’ll dissect the two schools of democracy, The Classical View( Lincolnian) and the Schumpeterian View.

 The classical view holds that majority rule is a mechanism that aggregates the preferences of all citizens, in order to create a popular or general will, precisely a Government of the people, for the people by the people.

 The more new-fangled, ”deliberative” view holds that, rather than aggregating interests, voting is more a mechanism through which citizens voice their opinion about where the common good lies. According to this Schumpeterian perspective, voting has less to do with advancing one’s interests, and more with contributing to an ongoing conversation.

This ongoing conversation is a centralised ideology. Where revolutionary leadership has taken place, what happens isn’t the mooting on whose opinion must hold, but on who shall withhold the pre-existing opinion and advance it to the next stage of execution. This is the most successful form of democratic centralism, Worked for China, Tanzania etc. The Communist party of China handpicks a cadre to carry on the revolution, So does CCM. The Juche ideology of the  Democratic People’s Republic of Korea though carried on by a family is effective . NB it’s called a Democracy by its citizens.   Not overhauling the system on every regime/ leadership change, but upholding the system. Nation building cycles back down to just decision making, how effectively these decisions are followed for execution to the later and a superior force to defend the decisions (state). These decisions in the case of Uganda could rotate around the NRA 10 point program, not that there are no alternative paths, but we as a country haven’t been offered those options. It’s a universal observation that none of these processes in the nation is void of inadequacies, be it flawless. But understanding that there should be room to go back to the drawing board and enact contingency plans. It becomes foolhardy self-defeating, for a system to be overhauled for 2% inadequacy and 98% efficacy.

Seeing the zealousness of Ugandan opposition fight tooth and nail to assassinate the character and demonize a system, because they Lack the satisfaction and hate of a specific leader, claim a need to obliterate then reconstruct, it defeats one of the chief universal laws of development “Negation of the negation”.

Citizens are, in Schumpeter’s view, “members of an unworkable committee, the committee of the whole nation.” They are fully aware of this, which is why “the typical citizen drops down to a lower level of mental performance as soon as he enters the political field. He argues and analyzes in a way which we would readily recognize as infantile within the sphere of his real interests.” This creates a type of vacuum, which in turn generates the need for effective leadership. Think of the typical situation in which about a dozen people are trying to decide which restaurant to eat at. Everyone is hemming and hawing, voicing suggestions and complaints, but nothing is happening. Finally, one person simply announces a decision, saying “I’m going to restaurant X. Anyone who wants to come With me is welcome.” The crowd falls into line, not because the decision is the perfect one, but simply because they’re hungry, and any decision is better than no decision. 

But, The deeply entrenched illusion, actually intentionally crystallized (by anti-establishment)opinion of democracy, should be the classical format of democracy. Where every citizen is equally heard, every view counts etc etc. But we know it’s not workable but simply a ploy to arouse revolutionary anger in the citizenry so as to serve the underlying goal of clinching power.

But we can all agree that it’s not workable, for example, if all opinions of all citizens were to be aggregated democratically, we would need mini referenda on everything, where hospitals should be built, where roads should be built etc, which would be extremely expensive and time wasting. But this voting or argument doesn’t cater for the technicalities, because most political involvement on the part of the common citizen is predominantly sentimental and biased to where one’s allegiance lies. So if a citizen was asked to vote on where to construct a road, most likely he’d choose his home area, so areas with high populations will get services and those with small populations won’t get. But is it favourable for national progress? Most funding of infrastructure is debt. If citizens use the power of numbers to democratically lobby for infrastructure like paved roads, it wouldn’t be bad in the individual sense, but would it be good in the national sense? Now that you have the road how is the debt going to be paid? Does your settlement as a big population where the road was redirected pay? But if experts and technocrats make a decision, probably the road would be built in a place where the contribution to the GDP is higher, but it’s stifled by access markets, in a sense that there is high probability of a return on investment to pay the debt. The decision is an expert opinion and workable not, a sentimental sense of entitlement, that in the end becomes unworkable. 

My verdict, what a successful Uganda needs isn’t merely classical democracy but a Schumpeterian approach, so what Uganda needs is an effective leader, to say, “I’m going to restaurant X whose with me?” with a group interest of safeguarding the ravenous group from starvation. The nitty gritty of how much money is required, who’ll drive etc is Worked out when a strategic endpoint is clear, not amorphous. 

A group without authoritative leadership with clarity of vision on where to eat will:

  1. argue about where to eat until they starve to death, if they have to eat as a group, or; 
  2. the group will disintegrate, and each person will go to the restaurant of their choice. That’s the extinction of cohesion and death of the group.

In as much as this approach can be termed as dictatorship by those who seek to undermine the system, it’s not it’s just misunderstood, because ideal aggregative and liberal democracy is unfeasible in a growing economy. A substantial amount of illiberalism has to be enacted for the sake of progress.

OpEd; by Murangira Rubongyera Muhwezi.

admin
Author
admin