National

High Court Denies Patrick Bitature’s Application Against Private Prosecution

High Court Denies Patrick Bitature’s Application Against Private Prosecution

The Commercial Division of the High Court in Kampala has dismissed an application by Ugandan businessman Patrick Bitature  and Simba properties Co. Ltd, Simba telecom, Linda properties and Elgon Terrace seeking a temporary injunction against Vantage and it’s agencies from commencing any private prosecution or legal action until final disposal of a pending contempt of court case.

Justice Stephen Mubiru on Tuesday morning dismissed Bitature’s application saying that his application “catastrophically lacks a legal basis.”

“The applicants’ (Bitature and his companies) need for such protection must be weighed against the corresponding need of the respondents (Vantage) to be protected against injury resulting from being prevented from exercising their own legal rights for which it may not be adequately compensated in damages if uncertainty were resolved in its favor at the trial,” read his ruling.

This ruling gives Vantage Mezzanine Fund II partnership legal leeway to privately sue Mr. Bitature and his companies; Simba properties Co. Ltd, Simba telecom among others.

The company is seeking to recover a 10 million dollar loan that it extended to Bitature eight years ago.

The judge pinned the legal mishap entirely on Bitature’s lawyer, Mr Fred Muwema who he said did not properly guide his client, and proceeded to directed the lawyer to personally pay for the costs of the application.

”This application catastrophically lacks a legal basis. The legal costs and time wasted in this litigation could have been avoided entirely if the applicants’ advocates had discharged their duties to the expected minimum standards of professional competence. It qualifies as a “rare and exceptional” case where it would not be fair for the applicants to bear the costs. The costs must be met by the applicants’ advocates in person. Consequently, the application is hereby dismissed. The costs of this application will be met personally by counsel on record for the applicants,” Justice Mubiru ruled.

Court documents indicate that in 2014, Simba Properties Investment Limited as the borrower and Businessman Patrick Bitature as the guarantor and promotor acquired a loan worth 10 million dollars from Vantage which was used to refinance a portion of Simba Properties’ debt and Simba Skyz Hotel.

The securities which includes charges over the company’s and Bitature’s shares and legal mortgages executed for the said borrowed money now stand to be auctioned.

The loan which was due for repayment in 2019 has since accumulated. Mr. Bitature, now under pressure to repay it, has turned to courts of law in a litigation claim that the contract was illegitimate and signed under duress and therefore should not be repaid as required.

Osbert Mwesigye
Author
Osbert Mwesigye