Chief Justice, Alfonse Owiny-Dollo, has said that he will not recuse himself from Kyagulanyi’s court case following a petition by lawyer Hassan Male Mabirizi to have him step down.
Mabirizi alleged conflict-of-interest, accusing the Chief Justice of being involved with the incumbent President Yoweri Museveni, who is the defendant in the court case in question.
Speaking today on why he refused to recuse himself from the case, Owiny-Dollo said that there is simply not enough evidence to back Male Mabirizi’s claims, calling them out as merely ‘alleged bias.’
“There is need to bear in mind that judges are part of any given society and have at one time worked or associated with various members of the society As such, any person asking a judge for recusal must do more than merely allege bias. There must be evidence to satisfy the test for bias.”
“I find that I was under no duty to disclose my status as a former attorney of the first respondent (Museveni) because it is already in the public domain in regards the appointment process. When a person seeks the recusal of a judicial officer or any person exercising quasi-judicial functions, the objector must pass the prerequisite standard test of recusal; otherwise, litigants would abuse the provision for recusal and turn it into an avenue for determining or choosing their preferred arbiters in their respective cases,” the Chief Justice added.
Mabirizi accused the Chief Justice of being a former Lawyer to President Museveni in the 2006 Besigye petition thereby questioning the impartiality of the Chief Justice now presiding over the case involving his former client.
“Owiny-Dollo, Chief Justice, was formerly engaged/ hired as a personal attorney/ advocate of the first respondent (Mr. Museveni) in the lead petition,” Mr. Mabirizi avered in his application.
He further stated that “Objectively viewed, Owiny-Dollo is disqualified by prior engagement described above from being sufficiently impartial to adjudicate the head petition at hand.”
He also cited the recent visit by Owiny-Dollo at Statehouse, Entebbe, which the Judiciary’s spokesperson, Mr. Jameson Karemani, bashed in a statement that Owiny-Dollo was attending the swearing-in ceremony of Justice Margaret Apiny, a newly-appointed judge of the High Court.
He said that Chief Justice Alfonse Owiny-Dollo used the swearing in occasion to present the Judiciary’s Budget estimates for 2021/22 Financial Year to the President as required by the Administration of Judiciary Act, 2020.
On Thursday 18th March 2021, the supreme court will rule on whether or not Bobiwine will pay for costs for withdrawing his petition, which the Lawyers representing Yoweri Kaguta Museveni, say was based on false and dishonest statements he made against the impartiality and independence of the Judiciary.

