Finance

Banks Cry Foul Over Judge’s Recent Ruling In Ham Vs DTB Case

Banks Cry Foul Over Judge’s Recent Ruling In Ham Vs DTB Case

The Judge’s recent ruling in the Hams case v DTB was spot on. The banks have had it too good for far too long!

The banks have often used their very powerful lobby the Uganda Bankers Association (UBA) to literally bully the government, the regulator and borrowers on how to run the financial service sector to their advantage. 

As a result, the number of borrowers they have literally sent to an early grave is unimaginable. The number of businesses they have driven into the ground in their sole pursuit of profit no matter what, is alarming and has caused untold misery and suffering to the populace. 

One wonders therefore why they are crying foul to the extent of claiming that the financial sector is going to collapse. They go further to claim that their capital will be badly eroded, a situation that could result in the collapse of the financial services sector leading to the loss of many jobs. 

This kind of alarmist narrative smacks of arrogance of the highest degree.

As if to suggest that the banks should be allowed to operate outside the law because if they don’t the financial services sector will collapse. How about the borrowers’ businesses if not the actual borrowers themselves, they have sent to their graves?  Selling off their securities for a song? 

This is a narrative many foreign investors use to try and escape the law and must not be allowed to obtain. We need foreign investors YES but they must respect our laws 

These foreign Banks must in no uncertain terms be held to account to the law. And that nobody, absolutely nobody is above the law. The law is the law! And this is what Justice Henry Peter Adonyo just did. Bravo Justice Adonyo. 

Ham aka Kiggs therefore should not be blamed for questioning and pointing out that the bank’s activities were not within the law and verged on outright Bank Fraud. 

The Banks have gone further to claim that this Judgement compromises their ability to syndicate loans. This a deliberate distortion of the facts to further cause alarm and despondency in the public domain, What the public should know is that syndicated loans  are allowed but this should be in accordance with the law of the land.

This will not be the first local investor targeted by the banks there is a litany of local investors that have been destroyed by the banks as we all look on. 

Simbamanyo Estate vs Equity Bank 

On August 16, 2020 Equity Bank through its agents advertised the intended sale of the mortgaged properties of Simbamanyo 

Investigations however reveal that this advert was in bad faith and manifested a motive to unjustly injure the name and business reputation of Simbamanyo and also in the hope of frustrating the ongoing court process. This is typical of  banks particularly Equity Bank. 

Simply put, the ongoing case involves the bank pressuring the investor and using illegal means and or transactions for the investor to borrow more than is required and then using the proceeds to balance their (the Bank’s) books.  

Details of Court documents filed by Muwema & company Advocates in the commercial court vide HCCS no 198 of 2020. Reveal that Simbamanyo  sued Equity bank for breach of trust, unethical and illegal conduct as well as engaging in predatory practices and seeks to question Kiggs the dealings it had done with the bank.  

Simbamanyo contends that as a regulated financial institution Equity Bank owed it a fiduciary duty to act professionally, diligently and give it (Simbamanyo), advice which is compliant with the law.

Particulars Of Breach Of Fiduciary Duty

Equity bank actively facilitated the procurement of two foreign banks to enter into illegal trans-national financial transactions in breach of its fiduciary duty to its customer to act with care fairness and reliability and transparency as provided by the bank of Uganda Financial Consumer Protection Guidelines 2011.

Equity bank exerted undue pressure on Simbamanyo to borrow US$ 10 million which was far in excess of the US$7.1 million owed to it promising Simbamanyo that the difference over and above the US$ 7.1m owed would be used by the borrower to complete his hotel project. 

As it turned out when the US$ 10 million was received by Equity bank it converted a substantial sum of the money obtained in excess of the US$ 7.1 million owed to it not only to balance its books but also to pay its brokers and cronies, leaving a paltry US$0.5 million excess to the borrower to meet advance interest charges as was provided in the new loan agreement. In itself a strange requirement! 

In addition to the above and unknown to Simbamanyo the loan transactions were also designed to escape regulatory oversight and also evade public taxation in Uganda.

Equity Bank on its part contends that the belated contention and/or allegation by Simbamanyo that the transactions from which it derived a benefit are illegal is made in extreme bad faith and with the view to escape payment of the loan

The bank filed a statement of defense requesting that regulation 13 of the Mortgage Act be imposed upon Simbamanyo which requires that if a person is to file proceedings against a bank they must first deposit 30% of the disputed sum with the Mortgage Bank.

This is the unfair regulation many banks use to stifle litigation against them and have pushed many borrowers to the wall. An injunction was granted to the company stopping the bank but with 30% condition in place.

THIS CONDITION HAS DEPRIVED MANY BORROWERS WHO HAVE BEEN CHEATED BY THE BANKS FROM A FAIR HEARING.

Many of these borrowers were victims of banks that had stolen money from them yet they were required to deposit 30% of the stolen money. 

Simbamanyo appealed this condition but to their chagrin the Registrar and the Judge hearing the case refused to lift that condition. 

Currently Simbamanyo is still battling this condition in court. Recently there was a near scandal when the bank tried again to shortcut the court process and irregularly sell the securities to one Sudhir Ruperelia of Meera Investments and another Luwaluwula.  Simbamanyo is challenging this irregular and illicit sale in the court of appeal. 

These are the well known mafias who have vowed to acquire every property in Kampala if not the whole of Uganda by hook or crook and set us back to the old order where we roamed the bushes with nothing to our name.

Standard Chartered Bank v Habib Kagimu Enterprises

In yet another case, In May, 2018 Standard Chartered Bank moved in on businessman Habib Kagimu over an allegedly unpaid loan of UGX 9.7b. 

Subsequently Standard Chartered Bank notified the public of its intention to auction Habib Kagimu’s properties against which the loan had been advanced.  The loan had been advanced to a consortium of companies among them Habib Oil, Habib Properties, 

Habib Brothers And Eagle Investments Ltd. 

A number of upscale properties including a residential house in Kololo others in Bugolobi and Sir Apollo Kaggwa Road, were advertised for auction on the premise that Standard Chartered Bank had failed to recover its money from Hahib Kagimu. However, acting through his  lawyers, Muwema &Company Advocates, Habib Kagimu disputed the figures in court stating that Standard Chartered Bank had inflated the value of the loan from UGX 7.7b to UGX 9.7b. 

Senana Vs Standard Chartered Bank

On September 24 2019, Standard Chartered Bank placed an advert in the local press to the effect that  Senana properties including a building on Buganda road another in Mengo and a warehouse in Busega were to be auctioned to recover a UGX 34 b loan. 

The directors of Senana had however on October 16, 20216 through their  advocates Kavuma Kabenge  Advocates applied to court seeking to restrain the bank or its agents from selling its properties. 

The company had by then challenged the manner under which Standard Chartered Bank was seeking to attach its properties claiming that whereas it had paid off the loan between 2016 and 2017, the bank had continued to send notices that contained false and manipulated amounts. 

Alexander Okello Vs Standard Chartered Bank

In April last year Standard Chartered Bank sold Okello house to State House . The sale came on the back of a protracted property dispute with businessman Alexander Okello who had lost the property for nonpayment of a loan that he had secured using Okello House and advanced to Pioneer Easy Bus Transport Company. 

Okello had also lost another of his properties Amamu House to Barclays Bank which was sold to Stellah Properties.

However while the banks are  getting  away with all this, the number of borrowers they have sent to an early grave is unimaginable, the number of businesses they have driven into the ground In their sole pursuit of profit no matter what is alarming and has caused untold misery and suffering to their borrowers.

Banks as MPS told them to their face last year when they met members of the Uganda Bankers Association are a bunch of thieves. One Member of Parliament after another demonized the Uganda Bankers Association (UBA) as a cartel of thieves who connive to fleece the public. 

There was a story recently in the local press where a prominent retired member of the bench complained bitterly how he had been fleeced by his bank manager of his savings amounting to UGX 150m. 

There was another story where one local bank tried to connive with the police to repossess his Hotel using fake/outdated court papers. The hotel owner complained loudly that the bank had faked (cooked) the figures to reflect that his loan had not been fully paid 

The other day the banks through their umbrella body the Uganda banker’s association issued a sanctimonious if not rather rambling statement that gave the impression that banks were saints and did not cheat their customers/borrowers. 

But everybody knows this is not true. Banks cheat their customers on a daily basis through unauthorized debits, exorbitant bank charges and high interest rates. They should therefore get off their high horse and stop charging high interest rates. Stop the mismatch between depositor rates i.e. the banks give 4% on fixed deposits and charge 17%-20% to borrowers. Is that fair?

The government needs to set the economic agenda by regulating banking activities and the financial sector and not leave it solely to the market, the crookes and the shenanigans.

The government needs to bring sanity to the financial service sector to protect its citizens from the marauding practices of these actors. 

And if the government will not do anything about this then our gallant MPs should do something to rein in these marauding banks by seeking to create a consumer Financial Protection Bureau to protect consumers from the unfair, deceptive and often abusive malpractices. 

The banks have often used their very powerful lobby the Uganda Bankers Association (UBA) to literally bully the government, the public and the regulator on how to run the financial service sector to their advantage. 

Sign 

Arc Peter Kamya

The banking system in Uganda in Uganda has recently come under so much scrutiny in how they “fraudulently” handle the loans. 

Renowned architect and businessman Peter Kamya, proprietor of the Simbamanyo, is in a court battle with Equity Bank Uganda and Equity Bank Kenya, with the former, through his lawyers Muwema & Co. Advocates, suing the banks for breach of trust, unethical and illegal conduct as well as predatory practices.

This comes at a time when businessman Ham Kiggundu is in a legal battle with Diamond Trust Bank around the same issues – foreign banks transacting unlawfully in Uganda. 

Peter Kamya contends that what he is going through with the Equity banks, and Ham Kiggundu with DTB, is a small part of a huge problem and it has to stop. 

Background.

In August 2012, Equity Bank Uganda and Equity Bank Kenya granted Kamya a USD 6 million loan to finance the construction of a hotel in Luzira as well as take over Kamya’s prior loan from Shelter Afrique.

Equity Bank Kenya was the lender that advanced USD 2.5 million while the rest, USD 3.5 million, came from Equity Bank Uganda. 

Loan payment problems arose and said in court that the bank was fabricating charges, which subsequently increased the amount he was supposed to be paying back. Owing to these issues, Kamya said that Equity Bank advised him to sell the land he owned in Munyonyo to raise money that would significantly help his loan clearance. 

The bank went on to broker a deal with Eritrean investors, the Bahamas group, to buy the land for Shs 5.5 billion, who was requested to make a 40% deposit, an agreement Kamya says he never saw. 

The Bahamas group would later put a caveat on his land and please to have it lifted fell on deaf ears. This was the start of the court battle. 

He sued Equity bank for the unlawful debiting of the loan account, whose debt stood at $7.1m, saying there were fabricated charges leading to the arrival of that amount.

The high court would later grant Simbamanyo an injunction, restraining Equity bank from selling the securities, on condition that Simbamanyo deposits 30 percent of the debt. This ruling was contested by Simbamanyo’s lawyers who said the plaintiff’s constitutional presumption of innocence was being eroded.

In efforts to have the matter settled out of court, the two Equity Banks brokered a deal with Bank One in Mauritius to lend USD 10 Million to the plaintiff to offset the old loan. 

Payments:

  • Equity Bank Uganda and Equity Bank Kenya received USD 10 million and paid themselves USD 8.1 million claiming it was the total amount due. 
  • An additional USD 1.32 million was taken by the banks as the brokerage fees.
  • Simbamanyo was required to pay USD 200,000 in loan processing fees, and USD 398,000 in interest. 

The businessman argues that he was bullied by the two Equity Banks into accepting the terms of the Bank One loan. 

“Equity Bank Uganda, in concert with Equity Bank Kenya, and Bank One stood in a stronger financial position as the lender and they intimidated, dominated, took advantage of and exploited the weaker position of the plaintiff as a borrower by making it enter into the illegal and predatory loan agreements largely meant to benefit the lenders and their brokers to the detriment of the plaintiff. The above statement clearly indicates that the loan outstanding to the 1st and 2nd defendants was only $ 7.1m and not $ 8.1m as claimed. Therefore, the defendants overpaid themselves by $910,476.”

Peter Kamya says that the Uganda bankers association shields their member banks and foreign counterparts into bullying clients.

“The banks have often used their very powerful lobby the Uganda Bankers Association (UBA) to literally bully the government, the regulator and borrowers on how to run the financial service sector to their advantage,” says Simbamanyo. 

Equity Bank had moved to advertise the sale of Kamya’s properties as Simbamanyo house and Afrique Suite in Luzira, an act that Kamya termed as extremely frivolous and outrightly disrespecting the court process. 

He is at the risk of losing the said Simbamanyo building on Lumumba Avenue, on which sits the Ministry of Gender, Labour and Social Development, and three plots of land housing Afrique Suite Hotel at Mutungo in Luzira.

Simbamanyo, through his lawyers, say they petitioned to halt the sale because they already had a case in court challenging the legality of the outstanding loan.

Commercial Court Queries Legality of Ham-DTB Deal And UBA Reacts To The Ruling

As Kamya battles Equity Bank in court, the commercial court, on 30th September, ruled that DTB’s auction can only happen after the legality of the transaction between Diamond Trust Bank-Kenya (DTB-K) and Kiggundu has been settled.

Kamya could not hide his delight when the commercial court stayed the audit process of the parties’ transactions saying that banks are bullies and make many unlawful transactions with the guise of saving the financial sector.

“Banks are bullies, and they use the powerful Bankers Association body to do it. As a result, the number of borrowers they have literally sent to an early grave is un-imaginable. The number of businesses they have driven into the ground in their sole pursuit of profit no matter what is alarming and has caused untold misery and suffering to the populace,” said Peter Kamya. 

“One wonders therefore why they are crying foul to the extent that the financial sector is going to collapse. They go further to claim that their capital will be badly eroded a situation that could in extreme result in the collapse of the financial services sector leading to the loss of many jobs.”

On 8th October, the Uganda Bankers Association, an umbrella organization that brings together 35 financial institutions in Uganda, and of which DTB is a member, released a statement saying that the ruling is going to put at risk over USD 1.53 billion (UGX 5.7 trillion) in the syndicated portfolio, exclusive of the lending to the Government Of Uganda. 

The statement goes on to proclaim that Justice Adonyo’s ruling has sent shockwaves through UBA’s international partners and this will affect Uganda as an investment destination. 

UBA goes further to call on the central bank, Uganda’s executive arm through the Ministry of Finance, Planning, and Economic Planning and Attorney general to pronounce themselves on this matter so as to cement the country’s position, with respect to investment credibility. 

Kamya says that the involvement of foreign banks is not only illegal but also alarmist. He says that banks claim that the financial sector and that statement is meant to the law in their favor. 

“This kind of alarmist narrative smacks of arrogance of the highest degree.

As if to suggest that the banks should be allowed to operate outside the law because if they don’t the financial services sector will collapse. How about the borrowers’ businesses if not the actual borrowers themselves, they have sent to their graves?  Selling off their securities for a song?” Kamya asks. 

“This is a narrative many foreign investors use to try and escape the law and must not be allowed to obtain. We need foreign investors, YES but they must respect our laws. These foreign banks must in no uncertain terms be held to account by the law. And that nobody, absolutely nobody is above the law. The law is the law! And this is what Justice Henry Peter Adonyo has just done. Bravo Justice Adonyo.”

October is set to be a momentous month as the courts of law rule on both cases. Legal analysts say that should the court deem these banks transacting illegally, the cases could as well be dismissed and the banks would have no locus to demand any money back. 

Peter Mukalazi
Author
Peter Mukalazi