Columnists

OPINION: Abortion is no longer a question of legality and illegality

OPINION: Abortion is no longer a question of legality and illegality

Abortion in Uganda like in other African countries such as Nigeria is legal only when performed to save the mother’s life. Therefore, Uganda’s law does not mean that abortion is legal but, that it is rather restrictive.

In some countries however, abortion has less restrictive laws. In Ethiopia for instance, the criminal Code of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia 414/2014 Art 551 permits termination of pregnancy in instances of rape, incest, where the continuance of the pregnancy or birth of the child is dangerous to the life and health of the mother, where the child has an incurable and serious deformity, and where owing to the woman’s physical or mental deficiency, they are unfit to bring up the child. South Africa has the Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 1891 of 1996 which allows abortion even without stated reasons.

The degree of restriction against abortion largely rests on the liberal rights exercised in the society in question. More liberal societies like USA and UK have less restrictive laws against abortion, while on the other hand, continents like Africa and Asia have more restrictive ones.

The situation at hand.

The consequences stand out, clear as the daylight.

Globally, 3 out of 10 of all pregnancies end in induced abortion. Nearly half of all abortions are unsafe, and almost all of these unsafe abortions take place in developing countries.

Between 2015 and 2019, over half of all estimated unsafe abortions globally were in Asia while 3 out of 4 abortions that occurred in Africa were unsafe.

An abortion is unsafe when it is carried out either by a person lacking the necessary skills or in an environment that does not conform to minimal medical standards, or both.

A critically low contraceptive prevalence rate of 39%, with the teenagers and the least privileged of the society less likely to access family planning services, coupled with a high total fertility rate of 5, means that more than half of pregnancies in Uganda are unintended and nearly a third of these end up in abortion.

With the poor and rural women, whose access to skilled services providers is constrained by infrastructural and financial limitations, more often than not, these opt out for unsafe abortions. Unsafe abortion and its complications account for 5% of maternal deaths in Uganda.

Arguments on abortion.

There are two sides to the notion of abortion, one for and one against. The one against legalization of abortion is called pro-life while the one that supports legalization is called pro-choice.

The argument by the pro-choice faction is that women deserve the right to choose what to do with their bodies. Put rightly so by the World Health Organization, “Every individual has the right to decide freely and responsibly – without discrimination, coercion and violence – the number, spacing and timing of their children, and to have the information and means to do so, and the right to attain the highest standard of sexual and reproductive health.”

On the other hand, the pro-life faction holds that the unborn fetus is a human being and a person, and if a fetus is a person and to kill a person is murder, and the law forbids against murder, then abortion is a crime punishable rightfully by the law.

We are left teetering between a rock and a hard place. The rock being the woman’s right to choice over her own body and the hard place being the fetus’s right to life. To legalize abortion would be equivalent to saying, murder is the lesser evil course-of-action to take while to maintain our stance on the matter is to impose on the woman’s right of autonomy to her body. And is the fetus part of her body or a separate being on its own?

A Christian concept of personhood maintains that we are all created in the image of God, and that God has called us into existence and continues to know and love us. Our dignity is intrinsic, rooted in the fact that God made us, knows us, and loves us, each equally; a fetus at conception as an adult past puberty.

However, there is evidence that liberalized policies on abortion curtail maternal mortality rates.

Abortion, in some countries, like China, has been used as an effective population control means reducing the rates of overpopulation. Abortion in China is entirely legal, available, on request, to all women.

Conclusion.

Uganda’s anti-abortion law is quiet ambiguous. In June 2015, the Ministry of Health attempted to clarify the ambiguous abortion law and developed the Reducing maternal morbidity and mortality from unsafe abortion: Standards and Guidelines. For the first time, Uganda had clear guidelines for the provision of safe termination of pregnancy and post-abortion care.

Three months later in December 2015, the government stayed dissemination. As of today, the standards and guidelines have still not been reinstated and the question of legal access to abortion remains undefined.

Without clear guidelines, women, girls and health providers are vulnerable to law enforcement personnel, who are unaware of the legal parameters for abortion. It increases the risk of misapplication of the law.

Pro-life and pro-choice arguments notwithstanding, the outright fact that abortion, most of which is unsafe, is occurring every day in the country is unmistakable. We are now way past the question of legality and illegality. The right question to ask is how can these unsafe abortions that are taking lives of countless women and girls be controlled in order to mitigate the alarming mortality rates that arise from the practice?

If you learned about your 15-year old son’s or daughter’s adamant indulgence in premature sexual activity, you can only hide behind the restrictive guard of ‘’do’s” and “don’ts” for so long. There has to come a time when you sit them down and educate them on why they need to abstain, but also on how to use protection in the event that they give in to their “immoral” urge. Till next time.

Osbert Mwesigye
Author
Osbert Mwesigye